Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-398-0716

TTY user 711 Mon-Fri : 8am-9pm EST

Medicare Advantage Plans vs Supplemental: 2027 Yearly Cost Math

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 18, 2026

In Medicare Advantage plans vs supplemental (Medigap) coverage, Advantage usually costs less in a year with little medical care, while a Medigap plan usually costs less in a year with a hospital stay or heavy treatment. In the illustration below, the crossover arrives once Advantage copays and coinsurance pass about $2,500 for the year.

2027 by the Numbers

$209.40

2027 Part B premium (CMS)

$9,250

2026 federal cap on in-network MA out-of-pocket costs (CMS)

$5,421

average 2026 in-network MA out-of-pocket limit, weighted by enrollment (KFF)

5,481

individual MA plans for 2027 (our analysis of CMS 2027 plan files)

Most comparisons of these two paths list features. This page adds up what a person would actually pay across a full calendar year under each path, once for a quiet year and once for a year with a hospital admission, using 2027 Medicare amounts where they exist and labeling every assumption.

If you want the feature-by-feature view instead, see our Medicare Advantage vs Medigap overview for 2027. For the cost side of Advantage plans in more depth, our guide to out-of-pocket costs in Medicare Advantage breaks down copays by service.

✔ Licensed in all 50 states
✔ Based on CMS 2027 data
✔ Free plan comparison

Key Highlights

✔

Both paths require the Part B premium, $209.40 a month for 2027.

✔

Medigap adds a fixed premium; Advantage shifts more of the cost to the moment you use care.

✔

An Advantage plan’s yearly out-of-pocket maximum sets the worst case, and plans choose their own limit up to the federal cap.

✔

In the worked example, the break-even point is about $2,524 of Advantage cost-sharing in a year.

Compare plans and enroll online

The Bills That Make Up a Medicare Year

A fair price comparison has to count every bill, not only the plan premium. Some bills are the same under both paths, and some exist on only one side.

Yearly bill Medicare Advantage path Original Medicare + Medigap path
Part B premium Paid by everyone Paid by everyone
Plan premium Often $0, varies by plan and county Medigap premium, varies by age, state, letter and insurer
Drug coverage Usually built into the plan Separate Part D plan premium
Cost when you get care Copays and coinsurance up to the plan’s yearly maximum Depends on the Medigap letter; Plan G leaves only the Part B deductible
Drug costs at the pharmacy Part D rules, capped at $2,400 in 2027 Part D rules, capped at $2,400 in 2027

The Part D out-of-pocket cap applies on both paths, so pharmacy spending is left out of the totals below.

Advertisement

Medicare Advantage Plan Comparison

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare 2027 Medicare Advantage plans with drug coverage from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-855-398-0716

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Scenario One: A Year With Little Medical Care

Picture a year with an annual wellness visit, two specialist visits, routine lab work and no hospital stays. These figures are illustrations, not quotes. The Medigap premium of $150 a month and the $400 in Advantage copays are assumptions chosen for round math; real premiums and copays vary widely by plan and area.

Line item Advantage ($0 premium plan) Medigap Plan G + Part D
Part B premium ($209.40 x 12) $2,512.80 $2,512.80
Plan premium $0 $1,800 (assumed $150/month)
Separate Part D premium Included $432 (assumed $36/month)
Part B deductible (2027) Plan rules apply $292
Copays for visits and labs $400 (assumed) $0
Yearly total $2,912.80 $5,036.80

Illustration only. Part B figures are the 2027 amounts CMS set on November 17, 2026.

In a light-use year, the Advantage member keeps about $2,100 that the Medigap member spent on premiums.

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-398-0716TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Scenario Two: A Year With a Hospital Stay

Now change one thing: a five-day hospital admission, followed by specialist follow-ups, imaging and several weeks of outpatient therapy. Under Original Medicare with Plan G, the Part A hospital deductible ($1,736 in 2026) and Part B coinsurance are paid by the supplement. Under Advantage, daily hospital copays and therapy coinsurance stack up until the plan’s yearly limit is reached.

Line item Advantage, $5,500 limit Advantage, limit at 2027 cap Medigap Plan G + Part D
Part B premium (2027) $2,512.80 $2,512.80 $2,512.80
Plan and Part D premiums $0 $0 $2,232
Cost-sharing for the year $5,500 (hits limit) $9,850 (hits limit) $292 (Part B deductible)
Yearly total $8,012.80 $12,362.80 $5,036.80

The $5,500 limit is an illustration near the 2026 enrollment-weighted average reported by KFF. The 2027 in-network cap of $9,850 is the figure reported from CMS’s 2027 Part C bid guidance; check each plan’s own limit, which may be lower.

The Medigap total barely moves: With Plan G, the yearly total in the hospital year is the same as in the quiet year. That predictability is what the higher premium buys.

Finding Your Own Break-Even Point

The two scenarios point to a simple test. Add up the fixed costs that only the Medigap path carries, then compare that number with what an Advantage plan would charge you when you use care.

1

Add the Medigap-only fixed costs Medigap premium plus a standalone Part D premium plus the Part B deductible. In the example: $1,800 + $432 + $292 = $2,524.

2

Estimate Advantage cost-sharing List the visits, scans, procedures and therapy you expect, then price them with the plan’s Summary of Benefits.

3

Compare the two numbers If expected Advantage cost-sharing stays below the Medigap-only total, Advantage is cheaper that year. Above it, Medigap is cheaper.

4

Check the worst case Look at the plan’s in-network out-of-pocket maximum and ask whether you could absorb it in a bad year.

5

Repeat each fall Advantage copays and limits can change every January, and Medigap premiums tend to rise with age, so the break-even point moves.

What the Out-of-Pocket Maximum Does and Does Not Cover

Counts toward the MA yearly limit

✔

Copays and coinsurance for covered Part A and Part B services from in-network providers.

✔

Hospital, skilled nursing, outpatient surgery, imaging and most doctor visits.

Does not count toward it

✔

The Part B premium and any plan premium.

✔

Prescription drug costs, which fall under the separate Part D cap.

✔

Extras such as routine dental or eyewear, which often have their own dollar limits.

✔

Out-of-network care in an HMO, which is generally not covered at all outside emergencies.

PPO plans carry a second, higher combined limit for in-network and out-of-network care together. The federal combined cap was $13,900 in 2026. Medigap has no out-of-pocket maximum of its own, but most letters leave so little cost-sharing that one is rarely needed; Plans K and L are the exceptions with a stated limit. Our page on whether Medigap plans have a maximum out-of-pocket covers those two letters.

Compare plans and enroll online

Our Analysis of CMS 2027 Plan Data

A break-even test only helps if you have plans to test. These counts come from our own processing of the CMS 2027 plan benefit and plan-county files, limited to individual plans open to the public.

5,481

individual Medicare Advantage plans filed for 2027

22

standard (non-SNP) plans in the median U.S. county

5

carriers selling standard plans in the median county

322

counties with five or fewer standard plans

In a county with two dozen plans, out-of-pocket limits can differ widely, so the worst case in Scenario Two depends on the plan you pick. Where only a handful of plans exist, there may be little room to shop for a low limit.

When the Cheaper Path Flips

Factors that favor Advantage on cost

✔

Few expected doctor visits and no planned surgery

✔

A plan with a low out-of-pocket limit in your county

✔

Your regular doctors are in the plan’s network

✔

A Medigap premium in your area well above the example

Factors that favor Medigap on cost

✔

Ongoing treatment such as dialysis, chemotherapy or frequent therapy

✔

A planned joint replacement or other surgery

✔

Long stretches spent out of the plan’s service area

✔

Wanting a yearly total that does not swing with health

Cost is not the only switch: Moving from Advantage to Medigap later can require passing medical underwriting in most states. Our guide on changing from Medicare Advantage to Medigap explains when that applies.

Bottom Line

The Bottom Line

Price both paths across a full year, not one month. Advantage tends to win when you use little care and Medigap tends to win once a hospital stay or long treatment enters the picture. Run the break-even test with real quotes and each plan’s own out-of-pocket limit before the December 7 deadline.

Compare plans and enroll online

Frequently Asked Questions

➤ Which costs less over a whole year, Medicare Advantage or a supplemental plan?

It depends on how much care you use. In a low-use year a $0-premium Advantage plan usually costs less, while in a year with a hospital stay a Medigap plan such as Plan G often costs less because cost-sharing is nearly eliminated.

➤ What is the break-even point between the two?

Add the Medigap premium, the standalone Part D premium and the Part B deductible. If you expect Advantage copays and coinsurance to stay below that sum, Advantage is cheaper for that year.

➤ Does the Part B premium change the comparison?

No. Both paths require the Part B premium, $209.40 a month for 2027, so it adds the same amount to each side. It still matters for your budget.

➤ How high can a Medicare Advantage out-of-pocket maximum go?

CMS caps in-network limits each year. The cap was $9,250 in 2026, and the 2027 cap has been reported at $9,850. Many plans set a lower limit, so check each plan’s Summary of Benefits.

➤ Are prescription drugs part of this math?

Drug costs are left out because the same Part D rules apply on both paths, including the $2,400 out-of-pocket cap for 2027. Only the standalone Part D premium is counted on the Medigap side.

➤ Why use Plan G instead of Plan F in the example?

Plan F can be bought only by people eligible for Medicare before January 1, 2020. Plan G covers the same gaps except the Part B deductible, so it fits most new enrollees.

➤ Do Medigap premiums stay the same every year?

Usually not. Many policies are priced by attained age and rise as you get older, and insurers can raise rates for everyone in a rate class. That shifts the break-even point over time.

➤ Can I use these totals as a quote?

No. The premiums and copays in the scenarios are labeled assumptions for illustration. Actual plan premiums, copays and limits depend on your county, age and the plans you compare.

Advertisement

Medicare Advantage Plan Comparison

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare 2027 Medicare Advantage plans with drug coverage from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-855-398-0716

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-398-0716TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a Texas limited liability company