Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-398-0716

TTY user 711 Mon-Fri : 8am-9pm EST

Medicare Supplement Plans vs Advantage Plans: The 2027 Side-by-Side

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated November 18, 2026

Medicare Supplement plans add to Original Medicare and let you see any provider that takes Medicare for a higher monthly premium, while Medicare Advantage plans replace Original Medicare with a private plan that has lower premiums, a network and copays up to a yearly cap. For 2027 the average Advantage premium is about $12 a month, while Medigap Plan G often runs well over $100 a month but leaves only the Part B deductible.

2027 by the Numbers

5,481

individual Medicare Advantage plans for 2027 (our analysis of CMS plan files)

$12

average 2027 Medicare Advantage premium (CMS)

193

counties with no Advantage drug plan in 2027, up from 123 (KFF)

15

states with a Medigap birthday rule as of 2026

Every person on Medicare chooses one of two roads: Original Medicare, usually with a supplement and a Part D drug plan, or a Medicare Advantage plan that bundles hospital, medical and usually drug coverage. You cannot hold both at once, and moving from one road to the other is not equally easy in both directions.

This comparison sets the two side by side with 2027 numbers, including our own count of the Advantage plans CMS approved for 2027 and the county exits that hit many members this fall. For the basics of combining or swapping, see can you have Medicare Advantage and Medigap.

✔ Licensed in all 50 states
✔ Based on CMS 2027 data
✔ Free plan comparison

Key Highlights

✔

Medigap: higher premium, any Medicare provider nationwide, few surprise bills.

✔

Advantage: low or $0 premium, network rules, copays up to a yearly cap.

✔

2027 brought large Advantage county exits, so plan stability is part of the decision.

✔

Switching back to Medigap later can require health questions in most states.

Compare plans and enroll online

How the Two Roads Work

Medigap (Medicare Supplement)

✔

Original Medicare pays first, the supplement pays most of the rest

✔

Any doctor or hospital in the U.S. that accepts Medicare

✔

No referrals or plan prior authorization

✔

Drugs need a separate Part D plan

✔

Benefits standardized by plan letter

Medicare Advantage (Part C)

✔

A private plan pays instead of Original Medicare

✔

HMO, PPO or other network rules

✔

Prior authorization for some services

✔

Most plans include Part D drug coverage

✔

Extras such as dental or vision may be included, depending on the plan and county

Not both: It is illegal for an insurer to sell you a Medigap policy while you are enrolled in Medicare Advantage, unless you are switching back to Original Medicare.

Advertisement

Medicare Advantage Plan Comparison

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare 2027 Medicare Advantage plans with drug coverage from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-855-398-0716

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

2027 Costs Side by Side

Cost item Original Medicare + Plan G + Part D Medicare Advantage
Part B premium Yes ($209.40 a month in 2027) Yes, same amount; some plans reduce it with a Part B giveback
Plan premium Supplement premium, often over $100 a month, plus a Part D premium Average about $12 a month for 2027; many $0 plans
Doctor and hospital bills Only the Part B deductible, $292 in 2027 Copays and coinsurance per service
Yearly cap on medical costs Effectively the Part B deductible with Plan G Each plan sets one; the federal in-network limit was $9,250 in 2026 and is higher for 2027
Drug costs Part D, capped at $2,400 out of pocket in 2027 Same $2,400 Part D cap when drugs are included

2027 Part B figures are from CMS (November 17, 2026). Advantage costs vary widely by plan and county.

The pattern: Medigap costs more in a healthy year and less in a heavy one. Advantage costs less up front and more when you use a lot of care. Our average cost of Medicare Part C page breaks down Advantage costs further.

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-398-0716TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

Our Analysis of CMS 2027 Plan Data

We counted every individual Medicare Advantage plan in the CMS 2027 plan files to see what the Advantage side really looks like nationally.

46%

of 2027 plans are HMOs, the most restrictive network type (2,531 plans)

33%

are PPOs, which pay something out of network (1,786 plans)

36%

are special needs plans limited to certain groups (1,965 plans)

481

plans carry a Part B premium giveback in their name

Strip out special needs plans and roughly 3,500 plans remain open to a typical enrollee; HMO and HMO-POS plans together make up 67% of the national total. UnitedHealthcare (822 plans) and Humana (793) file the most, followed by Devoted Health (740) and Aetna (651).

The 2027 Shakeup: Plan Exits and Stability

Medigap policies are guaranteed renewable: as long as you pay, the insurer cannot cancel you. Advantage contracts run one calendar year at a time, and 2027 brought large pullbacks, according to KFF’s October 2026 analysis.

2027 change (KFF) Detail
UnitedHealth Group Exiting 228 counties, entering 9
Humana Exiting 62 counties, entering 4
Health Care Service Corporation Exiting 498 counties
Counties with no Advantage drug plan 193, up from 123 in 2026
Average choice per beneficiary 28 Advantage drug plans

From KFF, Medicare Advantage plan availability for 2027 (October 2026). Check your Annual Notice of Change for your own plan.

If your plan is ending: When an Advantage plan leaves your area, you get a special enrollment period and a federal guaranteed-issue right to buy certain Medigap plans without health questions.

Switching Later: The Rules That Tilt the Choice

Moving from Medigap to Advantage is easy during the fall enrollment period. Moving the other way can be hard, because outside protected windows a Medigap insurer can review your health.

1

Trial right at 65 If you joined Advantage when first eligible and leave within 12 months, you can buy any Medigap plan sold in your state without health questions.

2

Trial right after dropping Medigap If you dropped a supplement to try Advantage for the first time and leave within 12 months, you can generally get your old policy back, or a similar one if it is no longer sold.

3

State rules Fifteen states have a birthday rule and Connecticut, New York, Vermont and Washington allow year-round enrollment, each with limits.

4

Everywhere else Expect underwriting. Read can you change from Medicare Advantage to Medigap before you plan on it.

Compare plans and enroll online

Which Road Fits Which Person

Medigap tends to fit if you

✔

Travel or split the year between states

✔

Have specialists you want to keep regardless of network

✔

Expect regular care and want a predictable yearly cost

✔

Can afford a higher steady premium

Advantage tends to fit if you

✔

Want a low or $0 premium and are comfortable with a network

✔

Value bundled drug coverage and extras such as dental, which vary by plan

✔

Use little care and can handle the plan’s yearly cap in a bad year

✔

Qualify for a special needs plan built around Medicaid or a chronic condition

Timing Your Decision for 2027

Window Dates What you can do
Annual enrollment Oct 15 to Dec 7, 2026 Join, drop or switch Advantage and Part D plans
Advantage open enrollment Jan 1 to Mar 31, 2027 One switch to another Advantage plan or back to Original Medicare
Medigap open enrollment Six months from your Part B start at 65+ Buy any Medigap letter without health questions

Leaving Advantage during either window does not by itself give you a Medigap guaranteed-issue right. Apply for the supplement first, and drop the Advantage plan only once you are accepted. More on timing: open enrollment for Medicare supplement plans.

Bottom Line

The Bottom Line

Medigap trades a higher premium for open access and near-flat yearly costs, while Advantage trades networks and per-service charges for a low premium and bundled extras. With 2027 county exits and strict switching rules in most states, choose the road you can live with for years, not just for next year.

Compare plans and enroll online

Frequently Asked Questions

➤ Which costs less overall, Medigap or Advantage?

Advantage usually costs less in a year with little care, and Medigap with Plan G usually costs less in a year with heavy care. Compare premiums plus your likely bills, not premiums alone.

➤ How many Advantage plans did CMS approve for 2027?

Our analysis of CMS 2027 plan files counts 5,481 individual Advantage plans nationwide, including 1,965 special needs plans.

➤ Can my Advantage plan drop me for 2027?

A plan can leave your county or end at the end of a year. If that happens you get a special enrollment period and a federal right to buy certain Medigap plans without health questions.

➤ Does Medigap include dental and vision like many Advantage plans?

No. Standard Medigap plans cover Medicare’s gaps only. Advantage extras may include dental, vision and hearing, depending on the plan and county; not all plans offer all benefits.

➤ What is the Medigap trial right?

If you join Advantage when first eligible at 65, or leave Medigap to try Advantage for the first time, you have 12 months to return to Original Medicare and buy a Medigap plan without health questions.

➤ Is a PPO Advantage plan the same as Medigap freedom?

No. A PPO pays something out of network, usually at higher cost, and only providers willing to bill the plan. Medigap works with any provider that accepts Medicare nationwide.

➤ Do I need Part D with a supplement?

Yes, if you want drug coverage. Medigap plans sold today do not cover prescriptions; a stand-alone Part D plan does, with a $2,400 out-of-pocket cap in 2027.

➤ Which states make it easiest to move back to Medigap?

Connecticut, New York, Vermont and Washington allow year-round enrollment, and 15 states, including California and Illinois, have a yearly birthday rule, each with its own limits.

Advertisement

Medicare Advantage Plan Comparison

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare 2027 Medicare Advantage plans with drug coverage from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-855-398-0716

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-398-0716TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a Texas limited liability company