Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated October 29, 2026
There is no official list of the top 10 worst Medicare Supplement companies, so the smart move is to judge each insurer on public data: its NAIC complaint ratio, its AM Best financial strength rating and its history of rate increases. A company that scores poorly on those checks is a worse bet than one with a low price today and a clean record.
2027 by the Numbers
1.00
NAIC complaint ratio that means complaints in line with company size (NAIC)
$283
2026 Part B deductible that Plan G leaves you to pay (CMS)
$1,736
2026 Part A deductible most Medigap plans help cover (CMS)
Many shoppers search for a list of the worst Medigap insurers before they buy. Lists like that online are often opinion, and they rarely show their data. A carrier that is a poor fit in one state can be a solid choice in another, because prices, rate filings and service records differ from place to place.
This guide takes a different path. Instead of naming names without proof, it lays out the 10 warning signs that should push a company to the bottom of your list, and shows you how to check each one yourself in about 30 minutes. If you are still learning how Medigap works, start with how Medicare Supplement plans work.
✔ Based on CMS 2027 data
✔ Free plan comparison

