Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-398-0716

TTY user 711 Mon-Fri : 8am-9pm EST

Top 10 Worst Medicare Supplement Companies? The 10 Red Flags to Check in 2027

Reviewed by Russell Noga, Licensed Medicare Insurance Broker (all 50 states) — Last updated October 29, 2026

There is no official list of the top 10 worst Medicare Supplement companies, so the smart move is to judge each insurer on public data: its NAIC complaint ratio, its AM Best financial strength rating and its history of rate increases. A company that scores poorly on those checks is a worse bet than one with a low price today and a clean record.

2027 by the Numbers

1.00

NAIC complaint ratio that means complaints in line with company size (NAIC)

$283

2026 Part B deductible that Plan G leaves you to pay (CMS)

$1,736

2026 Part A deductible most Medigap plans help cover (CMS)

Many shoppers search for a list of the worst Medigap insurers before they buy. Lists like that online are often opinion, and they rarely show their data. A carrier that is a poor fit in one state can be a solid choice in another, because prices, rate filings and service records differ from place to place.

This guide takes a different path. Instead of naming names without proof, it lays out the 10 warning signs that should push a company to the bottom of your list, and shows you how to check each one yourself in about 30 minutes. If you are still learning how Medigap works, start with how Medicare Supplement plans work.

✔ Licensed in all 50 states
✔ Based on CMS 2027 data
✔ Free plan comparison

Key Highlights

✔

Plans with the same letter pay the same benefits at every company, so service and pricing history decide who is worst.

✔

An NAIC complaint ratio well above 1.00 means more complaints than a company’s size would predict.

✔

AM Best ratings below the A range signal weaker financial strength.

✔

Big, repeated rate increases are the most common reason people regret a Medigap choice.

Compare plans and enroll online

Why Nobody Can Publish a Fair Top 10 Worst List

Federal law standardizes Medigap plans. A Plan G from one insurer pays exactly what a Plan G from another insurer pays. That means a bad company is not one with worse benefits. It is one that raises prices hard, treats members poorly or stands on shaky financial ground.

Those traits change over time and by state. A company might file a steep increase in one state and a modest one next door. Its complaint record can improve or slip from year to year. Any fixed ranking goes out of date quickly, which is why checking current data beats trusting a list.

Be careful with online rankings: If a list of worst Medigap companies does not show complaint ratios, ratings or rate filings, treat it as opinion. Some lists are written to push readers toward a specific seller.

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-855-398-0716

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

The 10 Red Flags That Put a Medigap Company on a Worst List

Use these warning signs as your own scorecard. One flag alone may not rule a company out, but three or more should make you look elsewhere.

1

1. High complaint ratio The NAIC complaint ratio for Medicare Supplement business sits well above 1.00, especially near 2.00 or higher.

2

2. Rising complaint trend Complaints are climbing year after year, even if the ratio is not extreme yet.

3

3. Weak financial rating AM Best rates the insurer below A-, or the company has no rating at all.

4

4. Recent downgrade or negative outlook A rating agency has cut the rating or warned that it may fall.

5

5. Large repeated rate hikes State filings show double-digit increases several years in a row.

6

6. Low teaser pricing The first-year premium is far below every competitor, which can lead to catch-up increases later.

7

7. Small or shrinking block Few people are buying the plan, so the pool of members ages and costs per person rise.

8

8. Enforcement actions Your state insurance department has fined or disciplined the company.

9

9. Slow or confusing claims and billing Complaint codes point to delays, billing errors or poor customer service.

10

10. Pushy sales tactics Agents pressure you to switch, skip health questions or buy a plan you do not need.

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-398-0716TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

How to Check a Company's NAIC Complaint Ratio

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners collects complaint data from state regulators. Its complaint ratio compares a company’s share of complaints with its share of premiums for one type of coverage. A ratio of 1.00 means complaints line up with the company’s size. A ratio of 2.00 means about twice as many complaints as expected.

1

Open the NAIC consumer lookup Search the NAIC website for its Consumer Insurance Search tool.

2

Enter the exact company name Use the legal name on the policy, not just the brand name. Big brands often sell Medigap through several companies.

3

Pick health or accident and health data Look for complaints tied to Medicare Supplement coverage when the tool breaks them out.

4

Review the trend and reasons Check whether complaints are rising and what they are about, such as claims handling or premium increases.

Tip: Some states, including Indiana, also publish their own health complaint indexes. Search your state insurance department’s website for a complaint ratio report.

How to Read AM Best and Other Financial Ratings

A Medigap policy is a promise to pay your bills for as long as you keep it, often 20 years or more. Financial strength ratings help you judge whether the company can keep that promise. AM Best is the rating firm most often cited for health and life insurers.

AM Best rating What it means How to treat it
A++ or A+ Superior Strong sign of stability
A or A- Excellent Solid choice for most buyers
B++ or B+ Good Acceptable, but check rate history closely
B or B- Fair Proceed with caution
C++ and below Marginal or weaker Red flag for a long-term policy

Ratings change. Look up the exact legal company name and check the outlook as well as the letter grade.

Pay attention to the outlook too. A stable outlook means AM Best does not expect a change soon. A negative outlook or an “under review” notice can be an early warning. For carriers that tend to score well on these checks, see our guide to best-rated Medigap insurance companies.

Rate Increases: The Biggest Reason People Regret a Medigap Choice

Most Medigap complaints come back to price. Every insurer raises rates over time because of rising medical costs and aging members. The worst experiences come from companies that start cheap and then raise rates sharply.

Warning signs

✔

Very low first-year price compared with peers

✔

Several years of double-digit increases

✔

Few new members joining the plan

✔

Rate notes that blame a small or older pool

Healthier signs

✔

Price near the middle of the market

✔

Steady, moderate yearly increases

✔

Large and growing membership

✔

Clear pricing method explained up front

Ask any company or agent how the policy is priced. Attained-age policies rise as you get older. Issue-age policies are based on your age when you buy. Community-rated policies charge the same price no matter your age. Which methods are offered depends on your state. Our guide to Medicare Supplement insurance rates explains how prices are set.

Compare plans and enroll online

Where to Find a Company's Rate History

Past increases do not guarantee future ones, but they show how a company manages its plans. You can often find this data for free.

Places to look

✔

Your state insurance department, which reviews or receives Medigap rate filings

✔

The public filing search many states run through the SERFF system

✔

State Medigap rate guides, which some states publish each year

✔

Your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP), which offers free, unbiased counseling

✔

An independent agent who can show increase history for several carriers

Good habit: Ask for the last three to five years of rate changes for the exact plan letter, state and pricing method you are considering.

What to Do If You Already Have a Poor Medigap Company

If your current insurer checks several red-flag boxes, you may be able to move. In most states, switching after your Medigap Open Enrollment Period means answering health questions, and the new company can turn you down. Some states give extra switching rights, such as a yearly birthday rule.

Same benefits

A new Plan G pays the same as your old Plan G

Health questions

Usually required to switch outside special rights

State rules

Some states offer birthday or anniversary windows

Keep coverage

Do not cancel the old plan until the new one is approved

Learn your options in our guide to switching Medigap companies, and never drop your current plan until the new policy is approved in writing.

Bottom Line

The Bottom Line

The worst Medicare Supplement company for you is the one with a poor complaint record, weak finances or a habit of steep rate increases in your state. Since benefits are the same by plan letter, check those three things before you compare prices. A few minutes of research can save you from years of rising premiums.

Compare plans and enroll online

Frequently Asked Questions

➤ What are the top 10 worst Medicare Supplement companies?

No government agency ranks the worst Medigap insurers, and lists online are often opinion. A better approach is to check each company’s NAIC complaint ratio, AM Best rating and rate increase history in your state.

➤ What is a bad NAIC complaint ratio?

A ratio of 1.00 means a company gets complaints in line with its size. A ratio well above 1.00, such as 2.00, means it gets about twice as many as expected and deserves a closer look.

➤ What AM Best rating should a Medigap company have?

Many buyers look for a rating in the A range, which AM Best describes as excellent or superior. A B++ or B+ rating is considered good, while ratings below that call for more caution.

➤ Do worse companies offer worse benefits?

No. Medigap plans are standardized, so a plan letter pays the same benefits at every insurer. The differences are price, rate increases, service and financial strength.

➤ Is the cheapest Medigap company a bad choice?

Not always, but a price far below competitors can be a warning sign. Some companies start low and raise rates quickly later, so check rate history before you buy.

➤ How can I find a company’s past rate increases?

Check your state insurance department, its public rate filing search or a state Medigap rate guide. A SHIP counselor or independent agent can also help you find this information.

➤ Can I leave a Medigap company I am unhappy with?

Yes, but outside your open enrollment or a guaranteed issue right, the new insurer can usually ask health questions and may deny you. Some states have extra switching rules.

➤ Should I cancel my old Medigap plan before applying elsewhere?

No. Keep your current policy until the new company approves you and your new coverage start date is set, so you never have a gap.

Advertisement

Medicare Supplement Quotes

Call a Licensed Agent Now

Compare Plan G, Plan N and more from several insurance companies in one call.

☎ 1-855-398-0716

TTY users 711  |  Mon–Fri: 5am–7pm, Sat–Sun: 7am–4pm CT

No obligation to enroll

Find & Compare Plans Online

Speak with a licensed insurance agent

1-855-398-0716TTY 711

Mon-Fri: 8am-9pm ET

ZRN Health & Financial Services, LLC, a Texas limited liability company